Rekey or Replace Locks? Business Locksmith Advice for You

Admin • September 18, 2025

If you’re a business owner searching for a business locksmith in Newport News, VA, Shorty Wallin Lock & Security is ready to guide you in making the best choice about your property’s locks. This article draws on our expertise to help you decide whether to rekey or replace your business locks. We’ll consider cost, security, and convenience to help safeguard your workplace.

Why Lock Security Matters for Your Business

Commercial security starts with your doors. Whether you schedule regular office upgrades or face an emergency, proper lock service is key. A business locksmith can help you prevent issues like lost keys or unauthorized access. Businesses often face risks with lost employee keys, disgruntled ex-staff, or simple wear and tear. Protecting your building, inventory, and staff should always be a priority.

Understanding Rekeying: What Is It?

Rekeying means changing the internal pins in a lock so old keys won’t work. A business locksmith uses this method to update security quickly when keys go missing or employees leave. Rekeying keeps the existing hardware but makes old keys useless. This can be completed fast and without disturbing daily operations.

Benefits of Rekeying

  • Cost-Effective: Less expensive than new hardware.
  • Quick to Complete: Finished in less time than changing locks.
  • Minimal Downtime: No need for major door adjustments.


Rekeying is especially helpful when staff turnover is high. If a former employee took a key, a business locksmith can rekey locks to restore security without replacing everything.

Full Lock Replacement: When Should You Choose It?

Replacing locks means installing new hardware. A business locksmith may recommend lock replacement when your current locks are broken, outdated, or don’t meet security standards. If locks are damaged from break-ins, or if you want to switch to a better system (like electronic locks), replacement may be the best option.

Benefits of Lock Replacement

  • Upgraded Security: Use advanced locking mechanisms.
  • Improved Durability: New hardware lasts longer.
  • Visual Update: Fresh look for doors and entrances.


If you want to improve your business’s image or upgrade to smart locks, a business locksmith can show you the best options for your space.

Security Risks: Employee Keys and Former Staff

Lost keys and staff changes put your business at risk. When an employee leaves and does not return their key, anyone could enter. A business locksmith often sees security gaps when old staff still have access. Rekeying ensures only current employees can enter. In cases of suspicious behavior or terminated staff, quick action is vital. You want to keep your assets, information, and people safe.


If you suspect a key was copied, or if you cannot account for all issued keys, a business locksmith can audit your locks and recommend the fastest solution.

A locksmith changing the core of a door lock of the entrance glass door.

Cost Comparison: Rekeying vs. Lock Replacement

Understanding costs will help you make a practical choice. Rekeying is generally less expensive since you keep your current hardware. It usually costs less in terms of both time and money. Lock replacement, however, involves greater cost upfront but may pay off in long-term safety and durability.


For most day-to-day situations, a business locksmith often recommends rekeying as the first step. Save full replacement for major upgrades or after damage.

Quick Comparison

  • Rekeying: Fastest, best for immediate security, lower cost.
  • Replacement: Better for upgrades, lasting quality, and higher cost.

Making Your Decision: Key Factors to Weigh

When deciding between rekeying and replacing, consider these points:


  • Security needs: Are current locks strong enough?
  • Budget: Will quick fixes suffice, or is it time to invest?
  • Future plans: Do you want digital access or more control?


A business locksmith can assess your specific situation. In many cases, rekeying solves simple problems. If your locks are old or unreliable, or you want advanced security, replacement might be the stronger option.

How to Get the Most From Your Locksmith

Work with an experienced business locksmith to get the best protection for your business. Schedule regular lock reviews after staff changes or security incidents to keep your property secure. Sometimes, a hybrid solution works—rekey some areas while replacing locks in more sensitive spaces. Tracking who has access to which areas and limiting keys to trusted employees can also help prevent issues.


Consider adding advanced security options, like access control or smart locks, for more convenience and safety. While traditional lock-and-key systems are effective, a business locksmith can recommend upgrades if your business needs change or grow. Staying in touch with your locksmith ensures your systems stay updated and your business remains protected.

Secure Your Newport News Business With Confidence

Business owners in Newport News, VA, know the importance of strong, reliable locks. The experts at Shorty Wallin Lock & Security are here to help you choose between rekeying and full replacement for your property. For peace of mind and long-lasting protection, consult with a trusted business locksmith in Newport News, VA. Don’t risk your business security—contact us today and reach out to the local team who cares about keeping Newport News companies safe!

Man replacing the core of a commercial glass door lock for business security improvement.
June 4, 2025
Secure your business with expert locksmith services from Shorty Wallin Lock And Security in Newport News, VA. Call 757-722-0883 for a business locksmith!
December 26, 2024
Discover how a business locksmith in Newport News, VA can quickly resolve emergency lockouts to keep your operations running smoothly. Fast, reliable service for businesses.